SYNTHESIS_OF_SAFETY_RESEARCH_RELATED_TO_SPEED_AND_SPEED_LIMITS

Summary:

There is evidence that crash risk is lowest near the average speed of traffic and increases for vehicles traveling much faster or slower than average. The occurrence of a large number of crashes involving turning maneuver partly explains the increased risk for motorists traveling slower than average and confirms the importance of safety programs involving turn lanes, access control, grade separation, and other measures to reduce conflicts resulting from large differences in travel speeds.

When the consequences of crashes are taken into account, the risk of being involved in an injury crash is lowest for vehicles that travel near the median speed or slower and increases exponentially for motorists traveling much faster. One of the major concerns in all of the studies is the travel speed before the crash. Emerging technology used in mayday, vehicle tracking, and adaptive speed control systems provide the opportunity to accurately and continuously capture travel speed. This technology should be applied in improving our understanding of the relationship between speed, speed variation, and safety.

When a crash occurs, its severity depends on the change in speed of the vehicle at impact. The fatality risk increases with the change in speed to the fourth power. International research indicates the change in injury crashes will be twice the percentage change in speed squared, and fatal crashes will be four times the percentage change in speed. These relationships are based mainly on speed limit and speed changes on high-speed roads. More research is needed to assess their applicability to low-speed urban roads.

In general, changing speed limits on low and moderate speed roads appears to have little or no effect on speed and thus little or no effect on crashes. This suggests that drivers travel at speeds they feel are reasonable and safe for the road and traffic regardless of the posted limit. However, on freeways and other high-speed roads, speed limit increases generally lead to higher speeds and crashes. The change in speed is roughly one-fourth the change in speed limit. Results from international studies suggest that for every 1 mi/h change in speed, injury accidents will change by 5 percent (3 percent for every 1km/h). However there is limited evidence that suggests the net effect of speed limits may be positive on a system wide basis. More research is needed to evaluate the net safety effect of speed limit changes.
Most of the speed related crashes involve speed too fast for conditions. This would suggest that variable speed limits that adjust with traffic and environmental conditions could provide potential benefits.

Despite the large number of references concerning traffic calming, very few reports include results of a systematic evaluation. In many cases traffic volumes as well as speed are reduced. As a result of the traffic diversion, crashes may be migrating to other roads. More research is needed to assess the system wide impacts and permit comparisons to be made among individual as well as combinations of traffic calming measures.

REFERENCES
M. Armour, "The Effect of Police Presence on Urban Driving Speeds," ITE Journal, Vol. 56, No. 2, 1986.
R. F. Benekohal, P.T.V. Resende, & R.L. Orloski, "The Effects of Police Presence on Speed in a Highway Work Zone: Circulating Marked Police Car Experiment," Report No. FHWA/IL/UI-240, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, D.C, 1992.
R. R. Blackburn, R. Moran, & W.D. Glauz, "Update of Enforcement Technology and Speed Enforcement Devices," Report No. DOT-HS-807 584, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, D.C, 1989.
N.N. Bowie, Jr. and M. Waltz, "Data Analysis of the Speed-Related Crash Issue," Auto and Traffic Safety, Vol. 2, Winter 1994.
P. H. Bowers, "Environmental Traffic Restraint: German Approaches to Traffic Management by Design," Built Environment, Vol. 12, 1986.
D. B. Brown, S. Maghsoodloo, and M. E. Ardle, "The Safety Impact of 65 MPH Speed Limit: A Case Study Using Alabama Accident Records," Journal of Safety Research, Vol. 21, No. 4, Winter 1990.
T. Brummelaar, "The Reversal Point in the Perspective Road Picture," Australian Road Research, Vol. 13, 1983.
M. Bulpitt, "Traffic Calming - Have We Given Everyone the Hump, or Is It Just a Load of Chicanery?" Highways and Transportation, Vol. 12, 1995.
M. H. Cameron, A. Cavallo, and A. Gilbert, "Crash-Based Evaluation of the Speed Camera Program in Victoria 1900-1991; Phase 1: General Effects; Phase 2: Effects of Program Mechanisms," Report No. 42, Monash University Accident Research Centre, Victoria, Australia, 1992.
S. M. Casey and A. K. Lund, "Three Field Studies of Driver Speed Adaptation," Human Factors, Vol. 29, No. 5, 1987.
S. M. Casey and A.K. Lund, "The Effects of Mobile Roadside Speedometers on Traffic Speeds," Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, VA, 1990.
E. C. Cerrelli, "1996 Traffic Crashes, Injuries, and Fatalities-Preliminary Report," Report No. DOT HS 808 543, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, DC, March 1997.
C. S. Chua and A. J. Fisher, "Performance Measurements of Local Area Traffic Management: A Case Study," Australian Road Research, Vol. 21, No. 2, June 1991.
J. A. Cirillo, "Interstate System Accident Research Study II, Interim Report II," Public Roads, Vol. 35, No. 3, August 1968.
D. Cooper, P. Jordan, and J. Young, "The Effect on Traffic Speeds of Resurfacing a Road," SR 571, Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1980.
A. Dahlerbruch, M. Rychlicki, and B. Vaziri, "Speed Humps: Implementation and Impact on Residential Traffic Control," Compendium of Technical Papers, ITE District 6 Annual Meeting, 1993.
O. K. Dart and W. W. Hunter, "Evaluation of the Halo Effect in Speed Detection and Enforcement," Transportation Research Record 609, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1976.
R. Elvik, "Effects on Accidents of Automatic Speed Enforcement in Norway," Transportaion Research Record 1595, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1997.
U. Engel, "The Effects of Implementation of 50 Km/H in Urban Areas," presented at Living and Moving in Cities, Paris, 1990.
U. Engel and L. K. Thomsen, "Safety Effects of Speed Reducing Measures in Danish Residential Areas," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 24, No. 1, 1992.
European Transport Safety Council, "Reducing Traffic Injuries Resulting From Excess and Inappropriate Speed," Brussels, 1995.
R. Ewing, C. Kooshian and M. White, "Traffic Calming State-of -the-Art," Draft Final Report, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, April 1998.
L. Evans, "Traffic Safety and the Driver," Van Nostrad Reinhold, New York, 1991.
Federal Office of Road Safety, "Feasibility of Occupant Protection Measures," CR102, Canberra, Australia, 1992.
B. N. Fildes, "The Perception of Geometric Road Curves," Ph.D. Dissertation, Monash University, Australia, 1986.
B. N. Fildes, G. Rumbold, and A. Leening, "Speed Behavior and Drivers' Attitude to Speeding," Report No. 16, Monash University Accident Research Centre, Victoria, Australia, June 1991.
B. N. Fildes and S. J. Lee, "The Speed Review: Road Environment, Behavior, Speed Limits, Enforcement and Crashes," Report No. CR 127, Federal Office of Road Safety, Canberra, Australia, September 1993.
M. Freedman & J. R. Esterlitz, "The Effect of the 65 mph Speed Limit on Speeds in Three States," Transportation Research Record 1281, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1990.
M. Freedman, Teed, N., & Migletz, J., "The Effect Of Radar Drone Operations on Speeds at High Crash Risk Locations.," Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, VA, 1993.
N. J. Garber and R. Gadiraju, "Speed Variance and its Influence on Accidents," AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, Washington, DC, July 1988.
S. Garber and J. D. Graham, "The Effects of the New 65 Mile Per Hour Speed Limit on Rural Highway Fatalities: A State by State Analysis," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 22, No. 2, 1990.
L. I. Griffin, III and R. N. Reinhardt, "A Review of Two Innovative Pavement Patterns That Have Been Developed to Reduce Traffic Speeds and Crashes," AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, Washington, DC, February 1996.
G. Halbert, L. Marabian, H. Yousef, and T. Murray, "The Neighborhood Traffic Safety Program: Implementation of a Residential Traffic control Program in the City of San Diego," Compendium of Technical Papers, ITE District 6 Annual Meeting, 1993.
V. Hamalainen, and S. O. Hassel, "The Giant Speed-Indicating Display in Police Traffic Control," Report No. HS-040 655, Central Organization for Traffic Safety, Helsinki, 1990.
D. L. Harkey, H. D. Robertson, and S. E. Davis, "Assessment of Current Speed Zoning Criteria," Transportation Research Record 1281, Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C. 1990.
E. Hauer, "Accidents, Overtaking and Speed Control," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 3, No. 1, July 1971.
E. Hauer, & F .J. Ahlin, J. S. Bowser., "Speed Enforcement and Speed Choice,"Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol.14, No. 4, 1982.
L. Herrstedt, "Traffic Calming Design - a Speed Management Method: Danish Experiences on Environmentally Adapted Through Roads," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 24, No. 1, 1992.
A. T. Ibrahim, and F. L. Hall, "Effect of Adverse Weather Conditions on Speed-Flow-Occupancy Relationships," Transportation Research Record 1457, Transportation Research Board, 1994.
H. R. Jacob, and M.J. Rich, "The Effects of Police on Crime: A Second Look," Law and Society Review, Vol. 15, 1981.
H. C. Joksch, "Velocity Change and Fatality Risk in a Crash-A Rule of Thumb," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 25, No. 1, 1993.
I. B. Kearns and K. A. Webster, "The Effect of Aerial Speed Enforcement On Traffic Crashes," Research Note RN 4, Traffic Authority of New South Wales, 1988.
G. L. Kelling, T. Pate, D. Dickman, and C. Brown, "The Kansas City Preventive Patrol Experiment: Technical Report," Police Foundation, Washington, DC, 1974.
K. Kjemtrup and L. Herrstedt, "Speed Management and Traffic Calming in Urban Areas in Europe: a Historical View," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 24,No. 1, 1992.
C. N. Kloeden, J. J. McLean, V. M. Moore and G. Ponte, "Travelling Speed and the Risk of Crash Involvement," Report No. CR 172, Federal Office of Road Safety, Canberra, Australia, 1997.
V. Knowles, B. Persaud, M. Parker, Jr., G. Wilde, "Safety, Speed & Speed Management," Transport Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, March 1997.
R. Lamm, E. M. Choueiri, and T. Mailaender, "Comparison of Operating Speeds on Dry and Wet Pavements of Two-Lane Rural Highways," Transportation Research Record 1280, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1990.
C. Lave, "Speeding, Coordination, and the 55MPH Limit," American Economic Review, Vol. 75, No. 5, 1985.
C. Lave and P. Elias, "Did the 65 mph Speed Limit Save Lives," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 26, No. 1, 1994.
W. L. Liang, M. Kyte, F. Kitchener, P. Shannon, "The Effect of Environmental Factors on Driver Speed: A Case Study," Paper No. 981397, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, January 1998.
T. Maekinen and H. L. Oei, "Automatic Enforcement of Speed and Red Light Violations: Applications, Experiences and Developments," Report No. R 92 58, SWOV Institute For Road Safety Research, Leidschendam, 1992.
D. J. Mace and R. Heckard, "Effect of the 65 mph Speed Limit on Travel Speeds and Related Crashes," Report No. DOT HS 807 764, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, DC, March 1991.
A. J. McKnight and T. M. Klein, "Relationship of 65-mph Limit to Speeds and Fatal Accidents," Transportation Research Record 1281, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1990.
J. M. Munden, "The Relation Between A Driver's Speed and His Accident Rate," Report LR 88, Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1967.
B. J. Mustyn and D. Sheppard, "A National Survey of Driver' Attitudes and Knowledge About Speed Limits," SR 548, Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1980.
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, "The Effects of the 65 mph Speed Limit During 1987: A Report to Congress," January 1989.
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, "Traffic Safety Facts 1995: Speeding," Washington, DC, 1995.
S. Newstead and N. Mullan, "Evaluation of the Crash Effects of the Changes in Speed Zones in Victoria During 1993-1994," VicRoads, Australia, June 1996.
G. Nilsson, "The Effect of Speed Limits on Traffic Accidnets in Sweden," Proceedings of International Symposium on the Effects of Speed Limits on Traffic Accidents and Transport Energy Use, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 1981.
G. Nilsson, "Reduction of the 110 Km/H Speed Limit to 90 Km/H During Summer 1989. Effects On Personal Injury Accidents, Injured and Speeds," Report. No. VTI-358, National Swedish Road & Traffic Research Institute Linkoeping Sweden, 1990.
J. O'Day and J. Flora, "Alternative Measures of Restratint System Effectiveness: Interaction with Crash Severity Factors," SAE Technical Paper 820798, Society of Automotive Engineers, Warreandale, PA, 1982.
P. L. Olson, D. E. Cleveland, P. S. Fancher, L. P. Kostyniuk, and L. W. Schneider, "Parameters Affecting Stopping Sight Distance," NCHRP Report 270, Transportation Research Board, 1984.
P. D. Pant, J. A. Adhami, and J. C. Niehaus, "Effects of the 65-Mph Speed Limit On Traffic Accidents in Ohio," Transportation Research Record 1375, Transportation Research Board, 1992.
M. R. Parker, Jr., "Synthesis of Speed Zoning Practices.," Report No. FHWA/RD-85/096, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, 1985.
M. R. Parker, Jr., "Effects of Raising and Lowering Speed Limits on Selected Roadway Sections," Report No. FHWA-RD-92-084, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, January 1997.
H. Peltola, "Seasonally Changing Speed Limits," presented at PTRC European Transport, Highways And Planning 19th Summer Annual Meeting, University of Sussex, Proceedings Of Seminar K, Volume P350, 1991.
K. V. Perrillo, "Effectiveness of Speed Trailer on Low-Speed Urban Roadway," Master Thesis, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, December 1997.
F. M. Pfefer, W. W. Stenzel and B. D. Lee, "Safety Impact of the 65-mph Speed Limit: A Time Series Analysis," Transportation Research Record 1318, Transportation Research Board, 1991.
Research Triangle Institute, "Speed and Accident, Volume II," Report No. FH-11-6965, National Highway Safety Bureau, June 1970.
R. A. Raub, "Removal of Roof-Mounted Emergency Lighting From Police Patrol Vehicles: an Evaluation," Transportation Research Record 1047, Transportation Research Board, 1985.
P. A. Rogerson, S. V. Newstead, and M. H. Cameron, "Evaluation of the Speed Camera Program in Victoria 1990-1991, Phase 3: Localised Effects On Casualty Crashes and Crash Severity. Phase 4: General Effects On Speed," Report No. 54, Monash University Accident Research Centre, Victoria, Australia, 1994.
G. J. Sali, "Evaluation of Boise Selective Traffic Enforcement Project,"Transportation Research Record 910, Transportation Research Board, 1983.
R. J. Sampson, and J. Cohen, "Deterrent effects of the police on crime: A replication and theoretical extension," Law and Society Review, Vol. 22, 1988.
S. M. Saunders, "The effect the Aerial Patrol Has on Vehicle Speeds," Report No. 11, Western Australia Traffic Authority, Perth, 1979.
F. K. Scharping, "Experience Report. 30 Km/H Speed Limited Zones in Hamburg. Speed Reduction Measures On Major Inner City Roads," Transportation Research Institute, Technion-Israel Institute, Haifa, Israel, 1994.
D. Shinar, "Curve Perception and Accidents on Curves: An Illusive Curve Phenomenon," Zeitschrift fur Verkerhssicherheit, Vol. 23, 1977.
D. Shinar and J. Stiebel, "The Effectiveness of Stationary Versus Moving Police Vehicle on Compliance with Speed Limit," Human Factors, Vol. 28, 1986.
J. Sliogeris, "110 Kilometre Per Hour Speed Limit - Evaluation of Road Safety Effects," Report. No. GR 92-8, VicRoads, Australia, 1992.
D. Solomon, "Accidents on Main Rural Highways Related to Speed, Driver, and Vehicle," Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, July 1964 (Reprinted 1974).
S. Spitz, "Speed Vs Speed Limits in California Cities," ITE Journal, Vol. 54, No. 4, April 1984.
F. M. Streff and R. H. Schultz, "65-MPH Speed Limit in Michigan: A Second Year Analysis of Effects on Crashes and Crash Casualties," Report. No. UMTRI-90-37, The University of Michigan Transportation Research Inst., Ann Arbor, 1990.
F. M. Streff, L. P. Kostyniuk, and C. Christoff, "Effects of Drone Radar and Police Enforcement on Travel Speeds: Test on a 65 MPH Freeway and 55 MPH Construction," Report No. UMTRI-95-22, University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute, Ann Arbor, MI, 1995.
J. W. Stuster, "The Detection of DWI Motorcyclists," Report No. DOT HS 807 839, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1993.
J. W. Stuster, "The Detection of DWI at BACs Below 0.10," Draft Final Report, Anacapa Sciences, Inc., National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, DC, 1997.
J. W. Stuster, "Experimental Evaluation of Municipal Speed Enforcement Programs," Report No. DOT HS 808 325, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington DC, 1995.
N. Teed, A. K. Lund, "The Effect of Laser Speed Measuring Devices on Speed Limit Law Enforcement in Charleston, S.C.," Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, VA, 1991.
S. C. Tignor and D. Warren, "Driver Speed Behavior on U.S. Streets and Highways," Compendium of Technical Papers, Institute of Transportation Engineers, Washington, DC, 1990.
Transportation Research Board, "55: A Decade of Experience," Special Report 214, National Research Council, Washington, DC, 1984.
J. R. Treat, N. S. McDonald, D. Shinar, R. D. Hume, R. E. Mayer, R. L. Stansifer, and N. J. Castellan, "Tri-Level Study of the Causes of Traffic Accidents, Vol. I: Causal Factor Tabulations and Assessment," Report No. DOT-HS-805-085, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 1977.
G. L. Ullman and C. L. Dudek, "Effects of Reduced Speed Limits in Rapidly Developing Urban Fringe Areas," Transportation Research Record 1114, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC, 1987.
T. Vaa, "Increased Police Enforcement Effects on Speed," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 29, 1997.
A. Vis, A. Dijkstra, and M. Slop, "Safety Effects of 30 km/h Zones in the Netherlands," Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 24, No. 1, 1992.
D.L. Warren, Chapter 17: Speed Zoning and Control, "Synthesis of Safety Research Related to Traffic Control and Roadway Elements Vol. 2," Report No. FHWA-TS-82-233, Federal Highway Administration, Washington, DC, 1982.
D. Webster, "Road Humps for Controlling Vehicle Speeds," TRL Project Report 18, Transport Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1993.
D. C. Webster, "Traffic Calming - Four Schemes On Distributor Roads," TRL Report 182, Transport Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1995.
D. C. Webster and A. M. Mackie, "Review of Traffic Calming Schemes in 20 mph Zones," TRL Repprt 215, Transport Research Laboratory, Crowthorne, England, 1996.
A. Weiss, R. Lucke, and B. Reischl, "Effect of Traffic Enforcement on Crime," Final Report, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Washington, DC, 1993.
L. B. West, Jr. and J. W. Dunn, "Accidents, Speed Deviation and Speed Limits," Traffic Engineering, Vol. 41, No. 10, July 1971.
H. Westerman, "Roads and Environments," Proceedings of the 15th ARRB Conference, Part 1, Australian Road Research Board, 1990.
J. Q. Wilson, and B. Boland, "The Effect of the Police on Crime," Law and Society Review, Vol. 12, 1978.
P.L. Zador and M. A. Cirrone, "Driver Fatalities in Frontal Impacts: Comparison Between Cars With Airbags and Manual Belts," Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, VA, 1991.
D. Zaidel, A. S. Hakkert, and R. Barkan, "Rumble Strips and Paint Stripes At a Rural Intersection," Transportation Research Record 1069, Transportation Research Board, 1986.